Sunday, February 24, 2019

Don't Hold Your Breath! Article Review: Berman et al. (2019)


            A recently released article in Scientific Reports details an extreme amphibian adaptation. In a study entitled “The Siberian wood frog survives for months underwater without oxygen,” Berman and colleagues explore hypoxic resistance in the Siberian wood frog, Rana amurensis. Contrary to popular belief, Berman et al. (2019) demonstrates that the distribution of R. amurensis in northern Asia is not necessarily limited by oxygen depletion in waterbodies that do not freeze. Like other cold-tolerant ranid species, R. amurensis can survive in cold climates like Siberia’s by spending the winter months (overwintering) underwater where it does not freeze. Since R. amurensis can also overwinter on land, many scientists believed that this species was more cold tolerant that others, allowing it to occupy a large geographical range in northern Asia. However, other studies have shown that R. amurensis does not tolerate cold temperatures better than other ranid species. Perhaps the secret to its large distribution then, as this study investigates, is its ability to survive in severely hypoxic, if not anoxic, conditions. Berman et al. (2019) demonstrates that waterbodies in this species’ habitat range are indeed extremely hypoxic, reporting oxygen levels of 0.2-2.1 mg/L. Further, the research team exposed R. amurensis individuals to highly reduced oxygen levels of 0.1-0.2 mg/L in sealed containers. Frogs in these containers were able to survive up to 97 days, with reduction in activity only occurring toward the end of the experiment. Two individuals were also transferred from one of these containers to another with the same reduced oxygen level, but also with a highly reduced volume of water on day 54. These individuals survived for an additional 24-25 days. These results suggest individuals of R. amurensis can highly reduce their oxygen consumption while still remaining active and can potentially switch to anaerobic respiration.
Many aquatic turtles also demonstrate hypoxic resistance, but such a characteristic in Amphibia is little explored. This paper reports the first known case of extreme hypoxic resistance in amphibians that overwinter underwater. Such research lends itself to a number of subsequent questions. Do any other amphibian species exhibit extreme hypoxic resistance? What physiological mechanism allows R. amurensis to survive in these conditions? Certainly these questions and more merit further research into the extreme adaptations of amphibians. Nonetheless, this study sheds light on the many amphibian anomalies scientists have yet to discover and explore.

Berman, D. I., Bulakhova, N. A., & Meshcheryakova, E. N. (2019). The Siberian wood frog survives for months underwater without oxygen. Scientific Reports, 9, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-31974-6




2 comments:

Jane Kelly said...

When I lived in Alaska, I was surprised and saddened when I found a frog that seemed frozen solid and dead in the backyard under the snow. A frog, in Alaska? Later I learned that Rana sylvatica, the wood frog, does indeed live even north of the Arctic Circle, and goes to physiological extremes generating extremely high glucose and urea levels to raise the intracellular osmolality. While intra- and extra-vascular fluid spaces froze, the high osmolality prevents cells themselves from freezing and bursting. In this article https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4331536/ blood urea levels up to 186.9 ± 12.4 μmol ml-1 were tolerated. I don't know what a "normal" urea level in a frog is, but in humans it is <20. While R. amurensis has evolved incredible hypoxia tolerance to survive in low oxygen waters, R. sylvatica overwinters under the leaf litter, freezing up to 60% of its tissues, stopping breathing and heartbeat. Amphibean adaptations are amazing.

Allison Welch said...

Very "cool" article! Interesting contrast to the freeze tolerance of L. sylvatica!